Grier Hamilton opens her front door expecting to see her prom date. Instead, she finds several police officers, and they are there to arrest her dad...for murder.

Someone has made a terrible mistake because there is no way her dad — a nerdy high school principal — is a serial killer. But everyone around Grier and her family is quick to believe the worst. Friends disappear, family relationships fracture, and the press descends like a flock of vultures. As Grier navigates the fallout of the unthinkable, one question begins to torment her...

What if it's not a mistake?

Trigger Warning: There are mentions of sexual abuse and suicide in this book.