Thomas, an introverted and nerdy 27-year-old dentist, has a new neighbor, Jake, a charming and outgoing 25-year-old massage therapist, moving into his apartment building. Jake and Thomas start bumping into each other every time they show up to or leave their apartments. One day the power goes off and Thomas, afraid of the dark, asks Jake to stay over for the night. They get along really well that night and start hanging out together after that. Feelings start brewing between the two but they both have doubts. Why? Well, maybe because, according to both guys, they're straight.