Samantha Talbot is looking forward to her fifty-year high school reunion, to be held on a ship, the Good Times, cruising the Caribbean. She hasn't seen the other members of her all-girl band for years, but most of all, she wonders if her old flame—"nemesis" might be a better word, since he always got her into difficult situations—Jack O'Neil will be on board. When he doesn't show, she pretends not to care. However, there's a surprise in store for her. Jack always was a prankster. She should have remembered that.