Twin sisters, Rachael and Riley, shared everything, an apartment, a business (Twin Cups), and, as it turns out, their love of Rachael's fiancé. Unfortunately for Rachael, she learned about her sister's betrayal when walking down the aisle in her Silver Linings Wedding Dress Auction Gown.

Toby Sauveterre has a crush on his favorite barista at Twin Cups, Rachael. But when he gets the nerve to ask her out, he discovers she's already engaged. Then his aunt hires a new employee who is brokenhearted over a ruined wedding and needs a fresh start. Toby suddenly believes in miracles in the form of second chances.