When office manager Millie Thompson joins an online dating site on a whim, her skeptical inner voice is quickly drowned out by the exciting new connection she finds with a man named BlueEyes72. Daily witty messaging leads to building an online bond fueled by shared passions for books, indie films, and sarcastic banter. Before even meeting in person, Millie finds herself falling hard for the charming Caleb Richard behind the striking blue eyes. But when their highly anticipated first date results in the shocking discovery that Caleb's profile pictures are outdated, Millie struggles with feeling betrayed by this cyber suitor. However, unwilling to relinquish the genuine mental sparks between them, Millie decides to give Caleb a second chance to turn their online chemistry into an in-person friendship. They slowly build a real-world connection through patient nurturing, texted apologies, and time spent over coffee. But just as Millie finally sees Caleb as a romantic prospect again, another obstacle threatens the future of this online-cultivated relationship. Will Millie ultimately find true and lasting love with the man behind the screen name BlueEyes72?