Deputy US Marshal, Perry Cole is back in the small town of St. Claire, and he didn't come alone. Joined by the FBI and a witness who could crack his case wide open, Perry hopes to finally track down one of the most elusive criminals he's ever targeted. But just as the hunt begins, a murder derails his plans. Now he must partner with the cute-but-snarky Deputy Sheriff Erin Kaminski to find the killer. Perry quickly finds himself getting distracted by the feelings Erin stirs up in him, and if he doesn't get his head back in the game, one of them may end up at the top of the murderer's hit list.

The locals wanted someone else for the Deputy Sheriff position, but Erin Kaminski knows in her heart that St. Claire is where she's meant to be. And finally, just as she becomes a familiar face to the locals, the FBI and US Marshals show up, making trouble. She wants them to do their job and leave, and so she becomes their local liaison. But when someone turns up dead, she wants to be the one calling the investigative shots. Instead, she's partnered with the admittedly charming, but overly skeptical, marshal who thinks her faith is nothing but fantasy. With Perry's constant questions and distracting lure, she needs to keep her head clear enough to see the danger creeping her way—or she'll end up losing everything.