In the heart of the Amish community she once left behind, Beverly's world is turned upside down. A desperate call from her father beckons her back after a decade of estrangement. The family's struggling bed-and-breakfast needs her financial expertise, and she can't ignore his plea.

But as she steps foot in the familiar yet foreign surroundings, old wounds resurface, and Beverly must confront her turbulent past with her stepmother. Amid the tensions and memories, something unexpected happens – she finds herself drawn to not one, but two men.

Caught between her Amish roots and the allure of the English world, Beverly faces an emotional whirlwind. Is this a test from God, forcing her to choose between the Amish man who embodies her heritage or the Englisher who ignites a different kind of connection?