A maverick teenage niece, a fledgling doggy treat business and a houseful of rescued pets leave PE teacher Sara with little time for romance, especially one with a conservative, pet-less attorney such as Todd, but when he needs help coping with a boisterous and endearing dog foisted upon him for the year, she finds it difficult to ignore her attraction to him. Falling in love with Sara doesn't make sense to Todd, but he's about to discover that the best things in life are out of his control. A collection of nosy friends and family will do their best to convince this dissimilar pair that they're better off together, but everything will ultimately boil down to one question: are their differences too great to overcome, or are they what makes them perfect for each other?