Clare is just a former high school nerd turned suburban mom. After being broken by her cheating ex-husband, she's not about to risk getting hurt again. But when former nerd runs into former cheerleader, Clare finds herself willing to gamble on a second chance at love.

After all the bright lights and magazine covers, Mary is searching for a simpler life in her hometown. She didn't expect to find middle-age butterflies and sweaty palms. A surprise reunion with the shy geek from high school gives her a chance to make the move she never did.

The closer they grow, the more clear it is that they're perfect for each other, but will Mary be able to break through Clare's fear and self-doubt to show her she deserves a happily-ever-after?