Paige has a love hate relationship with Valentine's Day, but finds herself drawn to the man who's become known as the Valentine's Killer, who has been terrorizing her small town for the last five years. Wanting desperately for the masked man to come and take her away.

After a traumatizing experience Zach fakes his own death and goes into hiding, becoming, The Valentine's Killer, honing his skills over the years, waiting for the day to get his revenge. Zach's as prepared as he'll ever be, or so he thought.

It doesn't take long for Zach to give in and bring his Forever Valentine home with him. Risking everything just to have her close again. He doesn't just want her with him, he needs her. Zach wasn't as prepared as he thought he was to face the ten women who broke him, but with Paige at his side, his little devil princess, together, they'll finish what he started.